I wanted to write this post yesterday but I was too tired to really do it justice. And to be honest, I think a little bit of justice is what this topic needs. I frequently come down on Americans (I know not all of you feel this way) for their homophobic/anti-gay legislature and policies. I don’t necessarily post my opinions, but I certainly have them. Well, today I am going to give my American neighbours a break and focus my attentions a little closer to home. Yup, it’s apparently a bad time to be LGBT in Ontario Canada.
We’re gearing up for provincial elections here in Ontario. The Liberal party is likely going to be trounced yet again, who knows what will happen with the NDP and well, I fear another Conservative party win. What does this mean? Well, let me show you. The following is an ad that was put out by the Conservative Party and it was and is still supported by the Ontario Conservative party leader Tim Hudak.
Now, because I’m me, I realized that a lot of these points are lacking context. I decided to look up the passages being quoted. As it turns out, these points are NOT from the Ontario K-12 curriculum (which I knew before reading the document), it is a teacher resource published by the Toronto District School Board to promote inclusion in schools.
As to the points themselves, allow me to put them in context.
The only reference to cross-dressing I found (in the annex) was regarding the following:
- · The Renaissance Transgender Association, Inc. www.ren.org/page2.html
- · This site includes a very useful guide for creating peer support, activist, and educational groups. It is primarily focused on cross-dressing.
I found the "fairytale" quote under the accomodations/extensions section of the larger strand meant to teach children about gender stereotypes. This means that they are in fact accomodations for certain students. The document reads as follows:
- Accommodations/Extensions
- Give additional support during the brainstorming session, providing clues for activities. Provide opportunities for students to express their ideas verbally, with pictures, etc. Provide pictures and photographs from magazines to illustrate activities and toys that reinforce gender stereotypes and as a means to enrich the Media Literacy aspects of the lesson.
- Have students cut and paste these items onto their lists.
- Read some traditional folk tales and fairy tales with the class. Have students write/illustrate their own “gender-bending” versions.
- Share stories, articles, and illustrations of people in the media and communities, who break gender barriers (e.g. female hockey player, male teacher who likes to cook or sew)
On top of which, I think it’s a good writing exercise where point of view and putting yourself in someone else’s shoes is concerned.
The Valentine’s Day thing sounded a little weird to me, so I looked that up too. Here’s what that was all about.
- · Kissing Booth
- · Set up a tent or other structure, in a central place, that students and staff can enter. Decorate with cherubs and hearts. Put together a slide show of anti-homophobic messages and have it run on a continuous loop on a wall nearby.
- · Before entering the Kissing Booth students and staff must complete a short 10-15 question school climate survey. In the booth, students and staff are greeted by students who place a stamp of a kiss on their cheek and a few chocolate kisses in their hand. Extend the Kissing Booth activity by informing all home form teachers of the event, ask them to announce it and provide discussion questions for the day after. Publicize the results of the climate survey that kissing booth participants filled out.
And lastly, the reference to teaching the book Gloria Goes to Gay Pride. Here’s the rationale and context behind that one.
- · Talk to students about the importance of this day to Gloria and her family. Explain to the students that Pride Week is a week when same-sex families celebrate their community. (This term and other related words such as gay, lesbian, and bisexual should have been introduced and discussed in the previous activity.) Be prepared to discuss aspects of Pride Week that students may have seen at the parade or in photos or news reports. Stress that the way people dress for a parade is different from the way they dress every day and that all gay, lesbian, and bisexual people don’t like to dress in the same way. Be careful that students don’t stereotype LGBTQ people based on certain images they notice.
I haven’t read the document in its entirety. It is over 200 pages. But after looking at the table of contents and perusing a bit, I will be contacting the Toronto District School Board to request a copy. That document is exactly what education needs. It appears to be carefully thought out, age appropriate, inclusive and sensitive to minorities. Children need to start learning early on how to be sensitive and understanding of people who are different from them. We don't accept racism or sexism, why do we still accept heterosexism? And you know what? Just because this subject matter isn’t being taught in schools, doesn’t mean that kids aren’t noticing it. Little Abby has noticed that her best friend Candace has two daddies. Who do I want informing my child? A teacher or other students who also may not understand? Teach hate and fear or treach tolerance and understanding?
To wrap up, I’d like to show you an ad that appeared in the National Post.
 |
| There's more to the ad, I just couldn't find another image large enough to be readable. |
All I have to say is that the only children who are confused over their identity (because of society at large and ads like these) are the children who are or will eventually will “come out” as transgendered, transsexual and so on. I don’t understand why intersex is there because I don’t think one can question whether or not they are intersex… I might be wrong on that last point.
So, a rather long post today, but it had to be said. I’m rarely ashamed of being a Canadian. When stupidities like this appear in the press and I'm reminded that hatred exists here as well, I am ashamed. We (all people around the world) should be better than this.
Here’s a suggestion for the up-coming election. Find a way to fix the economy. It won’t matter who’s gay, straight, bi or trans if we’re all broke and fighting for food rations.
Lauren.